Return of the Tooth Fairy 2020
Fifteen years after the first chilling encounter, Corey returns for his class reunion—only to discover the Tooth Fairy hasn't forgotten the cavities of the past.
Director: Louisa Warren
Cast
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Return of the Tooth Fairy (2020) about?
Corey returns for his high school reunion, unaware that the Tooth Fairy from his childhood trauma has returned for a deadly encore. This time, the mythical figure's rules are deadlier, and Corey must confront his past before his own dental neglect becomes his undoing.
Who directed Return of the Tooth Fairy?
Louisa Warren directed Return of the Tooth Fairy, bringing a fresh yet unsettling vision to the horror sequel.
Who stars in Return of the Tooth Fairy?
Jake Watkins leads the cast as Corey, joined by Katie McKenna, Gus Fithen, Chelsea Greenwood, and Simon Manley in key roles.
Is Return of the Tooth Fairy (2020) worth watching?
For horror fans craving a sequel that ups the ante, Return of the Tooth Fairy delivers twisted nostalgia with plenty of gore. The film's low IMDb rating doesn't reflect its cult potential—this is a B-movie with a cult following in the making.
How long is Return of the Tooth Fairy?
Return of the Tooth Fairy runs for 91 minutes.
About Return of the Tooth Fairy (2020) — A horror sequel where cavities cost more than a tooth
Fifteen years after the first chilling encounter, Corey returns for his class reunion—only to discover the Tooth Fairy hasn't forgotten the cavities of the past. Louisa Warren's horror sequel dives back into the nightmare that once shattered childhoods, transforming a familiar bedtime figure into a nightmarish guardian of dental hygiene. With Jake Watkins reprising his traumatized role, the film blends psychological dread with gory set pieces, where every unbrushed molar becomes a potential death sentence. The claustrophobic hallways of Corey's reunion echo with the same eerie giggles, but this time, the rules are darker—and the price of flossing poorly is terrifyingly literal.
Return of the Tooth Fairy (2020) leans into the unsettling duality of innocence and horror, where childhood memories curdle into adult anxieties. Katie McKenna's sharp performance as a skeptic who slowly unravels the legend adds depth to the carnage, while Gus Fithen's relentless pursuit of dental perfection turns the antagonist into an unforgettable villain. Shot with a neon-tinged nightmare aesthetic, this sequel doesn't just resurrect the boogeyman—it sharpens the knife.